[Return to The Indicator Online]

Amherst College's Journal
of Social & Political Thought

 
The Tribe Has Spoken, Mom

In its love affair with fantasy, the American public has lost touch with real-life struggles.

by MARCI BRENHOLZ

THE popularity of the television show Survivor has plagued me ever since the first episode aired and started the Survivor cult. After I heard many people comment that shows like Survivor portray contemporary society, I started thinking about life on Palua Tiga Island from the other side of the screen. In my examination of Survivor, the really intriguing piece of the puzzle was finding the reason that people would want to be on Survivor at all. There can’t be many people willing to go to such extremes for their 15 minutes. After all, Survivor cast members are required to give millions of people access to the most private details of their lives and even eat an occasional rat. There is no escape from the camera; private time does not exist. Yet there are a large number of people who seem to find the idea of being on Survivor appealing.

Upon considering this seemingly insane desire, a couple of reasons that a person would want to be a Survivor cast member come to mind. First, we are a culture of people who love being watched and each of us loves being the center of attention. On any of these “reality-based” shows, the participants can be sure that they have an audience of millions eagerly awaiting their next move. Another appealing thing about being a Survivor cast member is the opportunity to have an adventure. In a time when it seems that everything has been seen, done, and conquered, there is a constant search for novelty and excitement. There are few opportunities more exciting than venturing into the wilderness and taking a crack at surviving without the creature comforts we value so highly.

Deep inside most Americans is a born performer, a daring, kooky alter­-ego who wants to be watched. This stems from the fact that we are ever in awe of the great and powerful celebrity. We long to be known, talked about, admired, worshipped. There are very few people who realize their dreams of living in the limelight; however, a show like Survivor will give anyone a chance to be on television, a chance to be adored by the masses. In order to be on Survivor, you don’t have to be rich, cool, beautiful, or even talented. None of the Survivor cast members had a star quality, yet the American public was there, every week, watching them with fascination. Though there have been many celebrities in history who have become famous despite a complete lack of talent, Survivor has brought the talentless to a new height. There is a guarantee for the cast of Survivor that the American public will always be interested in them. A cast member of Survivor is perpetually being observed and, for many, that is the ultimate flattery. They understand the extent to which they themselves worship celebrities and the fact that the public now adores them is the ego-booster of all time.

Still, not all Americans spend their days dreaming about becoming a celebrity. Another appeal of being on Survivor is the search for a novel experience or achievement. At this point, it feels as if everything has been done. Your neighbors traveled to New Guinea, the Great American Novel has been written ten times over, and scientists have even made progress on cracking the DNA code. “What,” the average American may ask, “is there left to do now?” Survivor offers the ultimate new experience, not to mention a chance at a million bucks.

Survivor is the opportunity to do just what the title suggests: live from day to day. Middle-class America can be a pretty comfortable place and comfort can be stifling. Survivor is a challenge and, some might say, an opportunity to really live, to break the confines of monotonous daily existence.

Finally, Survivor gives people a chance to do, publicly, the one thing that people like to do best: whine. What could be more ideal? Every week, you get to whine, complain and whimper and not only will millions of people lend you a sympathetic ear but they will love every minute of it. Many people spend a lifetime looking for that one person with whom they believe they can spend the rest of their lives. Some people believe that we are searching for a soul-mate, and others for a life-long companion, but what many people really want is someone who will listen to them complain, day in and day out, for the rest of their lives. When that person stops listening, it usually results in divorce. Many middle-class Americans have everything they always believed they wanted but are still not satisfied. They crave being listened to because they really have nothing to complain about, yet there is still a nagging inside of them that drives them to self-pity. We are a selfish bunch who not only love to be watched and adored but also enjoy having others listen to our petty problems. The most appealing part of Survivor is the encouragement of whining. Without the whining of the cast members, the show could not go on. The residents of the Survivor island are given license to be catty, insulting, and just plain annoying. That is the very basis of the show and America eats it up.

Still, we are now left to question just how many Americans would take the opportunity to actually become a Survivor cast member. After all, one of the reasons that the show is so popular is the fact that we can sit on our living room couches and watch others struggle to survive. Although many fantasize about being on Survivor, very few would actually do it. This fact speaks volumes about the state in which our nation has found itself. The American middle-class seems to be a growing complacency. We are, as we have always been, a society of dreamers. In the past, Americans were known for taking action based on these dreams, and for changing the status quo. In this time of economic prosperity, it is very easy to get comfortable. Our prosperity has given us so much to lose that many have forgotten that we still have things to fight for. It is easy to watch Survivor and dream of adventure but, in the process of doing so, we have lost the revolutionary heart that Americans have possessed ever since we made a country of our own. Material comfort clouds our longing for change and improvement. We long to be on Survivor, forced to be bold, adventurous, to have the courage to live on an uninhabited island and make our way. In our communities, in our everyday lives, we are everything but brave. We are blind to the discrimination, homelessness, poverty, loss of personal freedom, and other problems that live in our backyard. Our love of Survivor represents the battles we refuse to fight, the misery we refuse to end, and the better country we refuse to build. It may be time to get up off the couch. eye_small.gif (1236 bytes)

Marci Brenholz '04 once dreamed of being a Survivor but has since reconsidered.

[Return to Top Of Page]

©2000 -- The Indicator, Inc.
Amherst, Massachusetts 01002-5000